Challenging
Read the following argument: 'The city council's new recycling program, implemented last May, is a resounding success. Participation has increased by 50%, according to city data. Clearly, this is the best environmental initiative the city has ever launched, and it proves our citizens are deeply committed to sustainability.' What is the primary weakness of this argument?
A.It fails to provide any verifiable facts to support its claims.
B.It uses a factual statistic to leap to a broad, subjective, and opinion-based conclusion.
C.The statistic about a 50% increase is likely false and cannot be trusted.
D.The argument relies on a prediction about the future rather than past events.
Challenging
An editorial argues: 'While the official unemployment rate fell to 4%, this figure masks the grim reality of underemployment and wage stagnation. Therefore, the government's economic policy is a demonstrable failure.' How does this argument use a reasoned judgment that is potentially biased?
A.It presents the 4% unemployment rate, which is a verifiable fact, as the main point of the argument.
B.It rejects a verifiable fact (the 4% rate) in favor of a purely emotional opinion.
C.It interprets a fact (the 4% rate) through a specific, negative lens ('masks the grim reality') to support a pre-existing biased conclusion ('demonstrable failure').
D.It makes a prediction about future unemployment rates without any supporting evidence.
Challenging
You are deconstructing a media article about a new technology. The first half details the device's technical specifications (processor speed, battery life, screen resolution). The second half is filled with phrases like 'a game-changer for the industry,' 'an unparalleled user experience,' and 'will likely make competitors obsolete.' What is the most logical conclusion about the author's purpose?
A.The author's purpose is purely objective, aiming only to inform the reader about the new device.
B.The author's purpose is to provide a balanced critique, showing both the pros and cons of the device.
C.The author uses an initial presentation of facts to build credibility for a subsequent, highly positive and opinion-based argument.
D.The author is primarily concerned with warning consumers about the potential downsides of the new technology.
Want to practice and check your answers?
Sign up to access all questions with instant feedback, explanations, and progress tracking.
Start Practicing Free